• Carl Barbettini
• Dick Beall
• Paul Bendele
• Hank Bonetti
• Will Brown
• Ted Davidson
• Mickey Davis
• Eddie Garcia
• Milt Guggia Jr.
• Dean Johnson
• Duane Long
• Jim Malloch
• Frank Romero
• Este Signorelli
• Bob Williams
• Don Wilson

2006

• Ray Anderson
• Rodger Brown
• Bruno Brunello
• Hank Curaza
• Don Gatewoood
• Harry Goodchild
• Hal Rabourn
• Rod Rodenberger
• John Rubcic
• Sonny Sumner

Santa Maria Indians Hall of Fame Committee

• Dean Johnson
• Rodger Brown
• Hank Curaza
• Hal Rabourn